We asked an AI assistant with live web search the questions buyers ask before they hire a local business, without naming the business. This is how often it was the answer.
Between September 24 and November 13, 2026, we asked an AI assistant with live web search 10,016 questions that buyers ask before they hire a local business. The questions came from 82 tests, one test per business, in 8 sectors. No question contained the name of the business being tested. For each answer, code checked whether that business was one of the companies the AI recommended.
When a person types a question into a search engine, the results page lists ten or more companies and the person chooses. When a person asks an AI assistant the same question, the answer names a few companies and explains why. In this study an answer named three companies at most. A business that is not one of them is not seen by that buyer at all.
Owners of small businesses usually do not know where they stand. They test it by asking an AI assistant about their own company by name, and the assistant answers politely about that company. That tells them nothing about a new customer, who does not know the name yet. This study measures the other case: the question a stranger asks, such as "Who is the best 24/7 emergency plumber in Dallas, TX?" or "How much does roof repair cost in Dallas for a small leak?"
67 of the 82 tested businesses are independent: a local owner, no franchise and no larger brand behind the name. Together they were tested on 8,533 questions. They were named in 151 of 8,533 answers, and named first in 84.
| Independent businesses | Businesses |
|---|---|
| Not named in any answer | 36 |
| Named in 1 or 2 answers | 18 |
| Named in 3 to 9 answers | 9 |
| Named in 10 or more answers | 4 |
| All independent businesses | 67 |
The few businesses that did well carry most of the total. The 4 independent businesses with 10 or more mentions account for 88 of the 151. The other 63 were named in 63 of 7,719 answers.
This result says nothing about the quality of their work. It says that when a stranger asks, these businesses are not on the pages the AI assistant reads and chooses from.
15 of the tested businesses are a franchise location or a local office of a larger brand, for example a national home-service franchise or a regional bank. For these, a mention of the brand counted. They were named in 299 of 1,483 answers, and 8 of the 15 were named in 10 or more answers.
One gutter franchise alone was named in 82 of 95 answers. Without it, the other 14 were named in 217 of 1,388 answers, which is still far above the independent group. A brand is not a guarantee: 2 of the 15 were not named at all.
A likely reason: a national brand usually has a page for each city, each service and each location, and it is mentioned on many other websites. That gives the AI assistant something to find for almost any local question in the trade.
Across all tests the answers named other companies 24,692 times. Those mentions are not spread evenly.
So each local market has a short list of companies the AI assistant returns to for many different questions, and a long list of companies it mentions once.
We counted how often an answer to a local question named a well-known national chain or franchise brand, such as a national handyman, restoration, plumbing or senior-care franchise. At least 3,313 of 10,016 answers did. In 29 of 82 tests the most-named company was one of these brands; among the 67 independent businesses that was true in 21 tests.
"At least" matters here. The count uses a fixed list of brand names that are national without doubt. Regional chains and less famous brands are not on the list, so the real share is higher.
Directories were rare as a named provider: 113 of 10,016 answers named a directory or list site, and in 1 test a directory was the most-named "company". That number is low by design, because the test asks for businesses, not for places to look them up.
Buyers do not only ask "who is the best". They also ask what something costs, how long it takes, whether they need a permit, what can go wrong and how to choose. We sorted every question by its wording. 8,900 questions ask for a provider. 1,116 are advice questions that do not ask for one; they come from 35 of the 82 tests.
| Type of question | Questions tested | Answers naming the tested business |
|---|---|---|
| Asks who to hire | 8,900 | 441 |
| Price | 246 | 4 |
| Time | 42 | 0 |
| Rules, licenses, law, insurance | 26 | 0 |
| Risk | 45 | 0 |
| How to choose | 112 | 1 |
| Other advice (can it be done, how it works) | 645 | 4 |
| All advice questions | 1,116 | 9 |
All 82 tests. A question that asks for a provider and a price in one sentence counts as "asks who to hire".
The answers to advice questions still recommended companies: 2,646 company mentions in 1,116 answers. The tested business was among them in 9 answers. For time, rules and risk questions together it was 0 of 113. For independent businesses only, it was 4 of 1,046 advice answers, against 147 of 7,487 answers to provider questions.
This is the earliest moment a buyer meets a company: before they are ready to hire, while they are still learning. The companies that answer those questions on their own websites are the ones the AI assistant quotes.
| Sector (independent businesses only) | Businesses | Questions tested | Answers naming the business | Businesses never named |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Auto services | 3 | 428 | 11 | 0 |
| Business services | 8 | 800 | 4 | 7 |
| Finance, accounting and insurance | 9 | 899 | 9 | 4 |
| Health, wellness and coaching | 7 | 1,120 | 40 | 4 |
| Home and property services | 23 | 3,223 | 44 | 10 |
| Legal | 6 | 510 | 3 | 4 |
| Other | 6 | 813 | 37 | 4 |
| Real estate and property management | 5 | 740 | 3 | 3 |
| All independent businesses | 67 | 8,533 | 151 | 36 |
In health, wellness and coaching, one dental practice accounts for 35 of the 40. "Other" holds a medical transportation network (17) and a youth mental health nonprofit (20).
Read the sector rows with care: some hold only a few businesses, and one strong business can move a whole row. What holds in every row is the size of the gap. In no sector were independent businesses named in more than a small fraction of the answers to their own buyers' questions.
The data tables behind every number in this study are published with it. Businesses are described by trade and area only. No business is named.
Mantas Auk is the founder of Mantas Auk LLC in Dallas, Texas. He has worked in search marketing for more than 15 years and helps local US businesses become visible in search engines and in AI assistants. He built the test method used in this study and a free public version of it, the AI Visibility Check on mantasauk.com.
Questions about the study or the data: mantas@mantasauk.com.
Six CSV files hold everything behind this study. Businesses are described by trade and area only.
To cite: Mantas Auk, “Who Does AI Recommend? 10,016 Buyer Questions About 82 Local Businesses,” Mantas Auk LLC, November 2026, https://mantasauk.com/ai-visibility-study-2026/.
Run the free check: 25 questions your customers ask, asked live, without your name. No email needed.